A Dangerous Plume

A Dangerous Plume

by Robert Garner McBrearty

I was in a small bookstore café, with a good selection but not an overwhelming number of books. The customers and baristas looked happy to be in this cheerful place of books and coffee. There have been so many big things to worry about in the wider world that this little bookstore café was a respite, a sanctuary from the storm.

I went into the bathroom, which was small and tidy, when I noticed a sign above the toilet: “Please close the lid before flushing. Avoid the hazards of toilet plume.”

My mother had vigilantly alerted me to dangers of all kinds, such as rabid animals and botulism, but concerning toilet plume, she’d left me on my own. A plume? I pictured a small pestilent cloud, a foul gas encircling my head and knocking me unconscious to the floor.

It occurred to me that I had not used the word “plume” in a very long time, though I wondered why as a wildfire had recently almost burned down our town and I might have thought to myself: there is a plume of smoke. But instead I only thought: there is a lot of smoke. In fact, run! Or drive actually. My wife and I and the kids loaded into the car and hauled ass along with everyone else in town. My wife said that maybe we should not look back. But we did. We looked back at the billowing smoke and the fire threatening to devour our home and so many others.

I found it curiously soothing now to focus my concerns on toilet plume. I’d spent a lifetime doing it all wrong, standing and staring, lid open, watching to make sure the water properly swished and cleared the bowl.

I read the warning again. It reminded me of my mother’s many admonitions, and it made me miss her, a sweet and funny lady, whose worries served as a guard against some deeper sorrow, and I thought that memories and thoughts are like plumes too, puffs of smoke leading on one from another, warm, dangerous, mysterious, and we run both toward and away from them. A sign in a restroom, and here I’m missing my mother, thirty years gone.

There was something in me now that wanted to rebel. I thought to leave the lid up and flush. Or maybe instead of flushing once, I’d keep flushing and flushing until the dedicated baristas, like first responders, rushed in to drag me from the gaseous plume.

But I followed orders. I closed the lid. I flushed. I heard a generous swish and swirl. As I crossed to the door to return to my safe little world of books and coffee, I stopped.

I felt a tension in my neck, a prickling in my scalp. Had the toilet fully flushed? I wheeled about. I had to raise the lid to check.

—

Robert Garner McBrearty’s latest collection of short stories, The Problem You Have (University of New Mexico Press, 2025), was a finalist for the Foreword Indies Book of the Year Award. His stories have been published widely, including in The Pushcart Prize, The Missouri Review, North American Review, and New Flash Fiction Review. A new collection of his short stories is forthcoming from Cornerstone Press, University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point.