Fiction by Xandra Kaste

Xandra Kaste
The Costume Party
Addie wouldn’t know anyone at the Halloween party, but Julia had assured her it wouldn’t matter.
“It’s going to be a bunch of people who don’t know each other either. It’ll be good for you.”
But now, as Addie stood outside the low-slung house and counted the cars in the driveway, her heart sank. She looked down at her outfit: a casual top, jeans, and Converse. Perfectly neutral. She’d wanted to be Mima from Perfect Blue, had spent months scrolling through pages of inspiration, even bought the dress off Etsy, but she’d known all along that she wouldn’t go through with it.
The party had started an hour ago—muffled hoots and yells echoed from the backyard. Addie checked her phone again; still no word from Julia. Classic. She screwed her courage to the sticking-place and climbed the steep hill to the front door. The voices inside hushed as soon as she knocked. As she stepped back, she noticed a sign taped on the door handle: “Come on in—it’s open.” She almost turned around and left. But what if someone opened the door while she was running away? She would never live that down. So, Addie pushed the door open, trying to make as little noise as possible. It opened into an empty living room. The backdoor shut behind the last person as she walked in. They had known she was coming, and they all left. No, don’t be stupid, she reasoned with herself. They were taking a smoke break. She could take advantage of this to find drinks and snacks unobserved.
The living room was remarkable only in how unremarkable it was. The furniture was a hodgepodge of banged-up Facebook Marketplace antiques with plywood IKEA furniture to fill in the gaps. Some effort had gone into the Halloween decorations—orange and purple hung from the overhead light to the walls. All the bulbs in the room had been replaced with purple ones. Someone’s Bluetooth speaker was crackling with ghostly howls and moans. A plastic jack-o’-lantern punch bowl sat on a card table in the corner of the room, and Addie made straight for it. Soon everyone would be back, and she wanted to be one drink in. She wrote her name with a marker on an empty plastic cup, then ladled the mysterious punch.
“Hi!”
Addie squeaked and sloshed half of her cup back into the bowl.
“Oh my god, I’m so sorry. I did not mean to scare you.”
A girl was tucked in one of the armchairs, invisible in the weird purple light, which hid as much as it revealed.
“It’s fine,” Addie said, and then stopped, unsure what to say next. “I mean, it’s Halloween.” The girl laughed easily. Encouraged, Addie asked, “Is this your party?”
“Oh no. The host is around here somewhere,” she said, looking around vaguely as if the host was hiding in one of the other chairs. “I love your costume, by the way.”
Addie wasn’t sure if the girl was mocking her, but the girl didn’t have a costume on either—just a nondescript t-shirt. “Oh yeah,” she said, doing a mock curtsy. “I obviously spent a long time on it.”
The girl’s reaction wasn’t quite what she had expected. Instead of laughing, she nodded seriously and ran a critical eye over her. “Well, it shows.”
Did she think Addie was dressed as something obscure? Addie was about to ask when the backyard door banged open, and one of the smokers came back inside to the punch bowl.
Seeing Addie there, she stopped and said, “Oh, hi! I don’t know you.”
“I’m Addie. I’m friends with—”
“Lol, good one,” the new girl said. “Can I get by you? Love the costume.”
Addie felt her face getting hotter. Her outfit must be alluding to something she didn’t know. How unlucky could she get? It was literally just jeans and a t-shirt; it couldn’t be more generic, but maybe that was the problem. It must be a joke, though. The girl getting punch was wearing a black dress Addie had grabbed herself at Target the week before.
“I love that dress,” she said, a tried-and-true conversational trick. “I actually just bought the same one.”
“I know. It’s perfect, right? I thought I’d go for a more contemporary reference.”
“Haha, yeah.” This was a nightmare. She could just ask what these costumes were, but then she’d look ignorant.
A small flood of people burst in and saved her from having to make further comments. It seemed like everyone was tired of being outside and had collectively decided to rush the snack table. Addie pressed herself into the corner, gulping down the jungle juice that had to be one-to-one mixer to liquor. On an empty stomach, the alcohol worked its magic, and the bustling crowd lost its edge of malice. No one was dressed up, and she felt a crushing relief that she hadn’t worn the Mima dress. She kept her eyes peeled for Julia, but she was nowhere to be found. As she searched the group, she kept thinking she knew people before realizing she’d never seen them before in her life.
Her cup was empty, and she headed back to the bowl to top it off. Everyone was standing around chatting now, and whoever was in charge of the music had cranked up the volume. The party was officially in fully swing. Only one person was by the punch bowl, a nondescript guy wearing a tee for a band she’d seen live a few years before. Her heart leapt, bolstered by her liquid courage.
“I love them,” she said, gesturing. “Did you go to their show? I have the same shirt, and I’ve worn it so much I have to tuck it in to hide the holes.”
He looked down. “Oh, no. This is actually just part of my costume. I need to check them out, though.”
She was finally drunk enough to brave asking. “What’s your costume supposed to be?”
He didn’t say anything, but with a proud smile, he untucked the shirt from his pants, revealing the holes in the fabric.
Addie stared at the shirt, trying to figure out what he meant. Then something clicked. The holes were in the same place as on her shirt. No, it was her shirt. Her mouth worked wordlessly. “How did you get that shirt?” she managed to ask.
“Spirit Halloween, but I put the holes in myself to make it more realistic.” A friend hailed him, and he wandered away.
Addie clung to the table. A group of girls walked by, all wearing clothes she’d worn to high school—one of them struggling to stay upright in the pair of heels Addie had worn to prom. The group of guys who were huddling near the TV to play Smash were in the various sweatpants and t-shirts that made up her pajama drawer. She even noticed two girls standing on opposite sides of the room glaring at each other, both wearing the outfit she’d worn to her first day of middle school. She tried not to notice how the people looked better in her clothing than she ever had.
If she’d had any doubt, she noticed now that all the cups people were holding said “Addie.”
Julia was pulling an elaborate prank; that was the only plausible explanation. Addie tried to make meaningful eye contact with passersby, to show that she, too, was in on the joke. Their gazes slid over her. Even surrounded by 100 mannequins of herself, she’d never felt more invisible.
Her phone buzzed, and it took her a moment to realize what was happening. The screen was startlingly bright blue in the hazy purple room, and she had to blink to adjust her eyes. The text was from Julia: “Holy shit dude I’m so sory my dumb ass sent you the wrong address. Pls don’t hate me the house is down the street from where I sent you.”
The room of people fractalized into a hall of funhouse mirrors. She was parading in front of herself, alternate realities of herself, laughing, chatting, all of them better versions of her. She had to go. Addie pitched forward, drunk now, and she kept bumping into herself, her one year playing soccer, her time at summer camp, the outfit she’d been wearing when—
Bile rose in her throat. Hunching over, she ran to the door. When they saw her pose, the crowd cleared a path for her, and she fell into the night air. After spitting out the acid, she silently typed in the directions; the house was a few doors down.
As Addie walked through the dead grass, static hummed in her ears like she’d been standing next to a speaker at a concert. A suppressed sob shook her body, but when it finally errupted out of her, it had transformed into a laugh.
When she opened the front door, Julia, dressed as a sexy nun, fell on her with apologies.
“I’m just so sorry.”
“It’s fine. I was just playing games on my phone in the car.”
“Okay, as long as you don’t hate me.”
“No, it’s really fine. I want to go outside for some air, though.”
Julia pointed to the backdoor, and Addie made a beeline for it. Only one girl was in the backyard, smoking a cigarette. She was dressed as Mima.
Addie’s shoulders rose and then fell. She walked over to the girl, who was scrolling on her phone.
“I like your costume,” she said. “Can I have a cigarette?”
“Sure!” the girl said, then passed it to her with a smile. “I like yours.”
“Thanks,” Addie said, and took a drag of the cigarette as she listened to the hubbub and laughter coming from the other yard.
The Body in the Pool

All of Miranda’s old swimsuits were too small for her now, and none of them accommodated the swellings on her chest. The tankini her mother had bought her was covered in magenta polka dots with foam cups that gaped open if she wasn’t careful. With a deep breath, she pulled off her eighth-grade graduation t-shirt and basketball shorts. Her back to the mirror on her closet door, she wrestled the suit on, taking care to pull the bottoms down over any of these new, disgusting hairs. She moved to leave, but the temptation to look was too strong; she darted a glance at the mirror and choked. The thing looking back at her was a marshmallow shoved into a swimsuit as a cruel joke. Neon white flesh bunched and rippled where the swimsuit cut into the stomach and legs, but it hung loose around her chest. The swollen, purple stretchmarks striping the inner thighs were a mocking echo of the polka dots on the suit itself. And above it all was a fat, zitty face. She did not know herself.
In the backseat of the Suburban, Miranda held back tears as her mother and sister compared the merits of tanning outside versus in tanning beds. All the while, Miranda floated above the car, watching the body she’d become.
Even before they were inside the clanging metal fence, the chlorine stung Miranda’s eyes. The pool was nearly at maximum capacity, and people’s yells and children’s shrieks bounced off the water and tile. Everything was bright and loud and tinny and grating. The pool butted up against the neighborhood’s creek and greenbelt, and the trees loomed strange and dark over the lurid scene.
Miranda’s flip-flops thwacked the pavement, sounding a dull drumbeat. Faces, pale with sunscreen, turned to watch as she made the long walk to the lounge chair. She hugged the towels to her chest, trying to cherish the few precious moments before she’d be truly exposed to everyone.
Safely at the chair, she released the breath she’d been holding and planned her next move. There were two swimming pools to decide between—one for the adults and one for the children. Before, she would have slapped her goggles on, grabbed the diving toys, and crashed into the water, but everything was different and worse now. Now, she was stuck like the gum on the heel of her purple flip-flop, hunched on the end of the sticky plastic lounge chair.
Next to Miranda, her sister took off her cover-up and stretched her arms above her head, elongating her slim body and showing off a chest that filled out her pink string bikini. All the lifeguards looked over as she sat on a reclining deckchair, languorously rubbing tanning oil on her legs, her eyes shaded by her sunglasses, a slight smile on her lips. If Miranda could have, she would have pushed her sister into the water and held her under.
Instead, she stood and turned to her mother. “Can I have a dollar?”
Eyes closed against the sun, her mother’s nose scrunched. “Why?”
“I want a snow cone.”
“In the pool bag pocket,” her mother waved her hand in its general direction. “Just don’t get any stains on your new suit.”
Miranda was taller than the rest of the kids in line for a snow cone. Clutching her tiger’s blood prize, she looked for anywhere she could shelter. Miraculously, an empty table sat in a corner shaded by the overhanging trees, so she pulled herself on top, pushing her fingers through the plastic holes in the lunch table. With her back to everyone, shrouded in darkness, it was almost like she didn’t exist. The trees were cool and dank and dark. She could just slip under the fence, maybe losing the idiotic tankini in the brambles. She could braid her hair with dead leaves and twigs, rub herself with mud, then decorate herself with moss and bark. And if anyone came to her woods, she would chase them away and laugh and laugh until her sides shook.
With her eyes squeezed shut, the snow cone dripping down her arm, she could almost see it all.
“Hey, dumbass.” Miranda yelped and turned around. Her sister was standing behind her, hand on hip, smacking her gum. “Mom told me to tell you to stop being a weirdo and either get in the pool or sit down with us. You totally got snow cone juice on yourself too. Jesus.”
Her mother was sitting up on the pool chair, peering over her sunglasses, lips pursed.
Beaten, Miranda slunk to a trashcan to throw away the soggy cone and hurried to the adult pool before her mother could say anything about the stain. She waited until the last moment to discard her towel, then slipped into the water, gasping at the shock of the cold, letting it punish her. Once she adjusted, she bobbed around the edges of the pool, her eyes out of the water and her mouth submerged. The people waved about like seaweed, their legs kicking aimlessly. She looked at the red stain across her chest and pretended she’d been shot.
A three-year-old girl in an Elsa one-piece toddled over to watch Miranda. She stood with her feet firmly planted, her belly proud, her mouth ringed by snow cone juice as she looked Miranda dead in the eye. Miranda held the girl’s steady gaze until the bright day turned to a dark tunnel lit only by the accusation in the child’s eyes. Miranda looked away. Bored, the child pattered off to stare at a woman in a wheelchair.
Taking a deep breath and then letting it out, Miranda sank to the bottom of the pool, her eyes open and burning in the chlorine. She sat bobbing against the bottom, watching the disembodied legs kicking above her and staring at the red stain on her chest, until her lungs burned and she thought she might die.
—


